http://www.csmonitor.com/2001/0823/p6s1-wome.htm
Israeli riot-gear sale fuels concern
Israelis debate the pending sale of water cannons, armored vehicles to
Zimbabwe regime.
By Ben Lynfield
Special to The Christian Science Monitor
August 23, 2001
JERUSALEM - A kibbutz that markets low-grade chemical weapons is
poised to sell millions of dollars worth of "riot-control equipment"
to Zimbabwe in a move its critics warn will translate into heightened
repression by President Robert Mugabe's regime (see story). But the
firm, the Beit Alfa Trailer Company (BAT), insists its intention to
sell equipment to Zimbabwe is actually humane: Demonstrators would be
faced with water cannons, not live ammunition.
This is far from the first time Israel has supplied weaponry to a
state increasingly considered an international pariah. Analysts say
Israel's defense industrial complex - which is US-subsidized, and is
massive for a country its size - is becoming one of the world's most
competitive arms exporters. China, India, Burma, and Zambia are
Israeli customers, despite the fact that the US either embargoes or
severely restricts its own arms sales to those countries, says a Tel
Aviv University study.
The UN reportedly had asked Israel to stop supplying both sides of the
Ethiopian-Eritrean war, including an air-surveillance system to
Ethiopia and two navy boats to Eritrea, according to Ha'aretz, an
Israeli daily.
Israel and South Africa's apartheid regime had a close
defense-production relationship across a broad range of armaments,
including nuclear weapons, according to Africa Business magazine.
The issue of BAT sales to Zimbabwe emerged in public discussion last
week when Alon Liel, a former director-general of the foreign ministry
and a former ambassador to Harare, wrote an opinion piece in Ha'aretz
expressing revulsion that equipment produced on a kibbutz, Beit Alfa,
would be used "to pursue the courageous proponents of democracy or the
farmers trying to continue working their land, or against the thousand
frightened Jewish citizens."
According to the website, www.bat.co.il, BAT builds riot-control
vehicles and specializes in water-cannon technology. The chemical
additives - to be used in restraining "dangerous inmate situations" in
correctional facilities - "can be injected in the water stream, under
further officer control, to further restrain and demobilize the
inmate." Reuven Canfi, BAT general manager, says the chemical is a
"food color" that aims at having "a psychological effect." But the
website suggests other chemicals, such as pepper spray, can be
injected into the cannon's water stream.
The company prides itself on producing nonlethal products that provide
alternatives to opening fire. But its equipment has other uses. BAT
sells an armored vehicle that comes with gun ports - which is
basically an armored personnel carrier. Mr. Canfi says the latter
type of vehicle would not be sold to Zimbabwe and that the planned
transaction would concern only riot control vehicles that use water
cannons.
The Zimbabwean newspaper, Financial Gazette, reported recently that
Zimbabwe was seeking at least 30 riot control vehicles as part of a
$10 million deal with BAT. Canfi says BAT plans to sell a much smaller
number of vehicles in a deal amounting to far less than $10 million,
but he would not specify.
"As long as they are using water with food color, instead of live
ammunition, I'm happy," Canfi says. "It does not matter if it is
Zimbabwe, Chile, or Angola, we help the government to save lives."
In 30 years of business, BAT counts among its customers the Israeli
security forces.
The company started negotiating sales in Africa about a year ago, he
says, with South Africa as one of its customers. During the 1980s,
Israel maintained a close security alliance with South Africa while
Pretoria was supplying Iran and Iraq, according to Africa Business.
But even South Africa, which sells arms to Zimbabwe, is debating
suspending those sales.
Yuval Steinitz, a legislator from Prime Minister Ariel Sharon's Likud
party, says he supports supplying Zimbabwe. "Beit Alfa cars usually
end up saving lives of demonstrators. We would be happy if Saddam
Hussein and the Syrians used them. I would be happy if the Chinese in
Tiananmen Square had used only water cannons."
An Israeli official says the government "has a mechanism, including
many checks and balances, that take into consideration all the
sensitivities. When there is a fear that a sale would affect civilians
in an internal conflict, we simply stop it."
"I think this is outrageous, and I don't think it helps
Israel-Zimbabwe relations," said Nomi Chazan, a member of the Knesset
from the liberal Meretz party. Israel, she say, should be forging
ties with the people of Zimbabwe.
